
When can employers withdraw meal vouchers and what are the consequences?
Meal vouchers during remote working are not automatically withdrawn, but neither are they guaranteed. Whether an employer can withdraw them depends on their purpose and the provisions of the collective bargaining agreement, employment contract or internal agreements.
Remote working has become a common way of organising work in many companies, raising practical questions about what happens to employee benefits that were previously linked to working on-site.
Is there a general right to meal vouchers?
No. This entitlement usually arises from a collective bargaining agreement, employment contract or company policy. What the law protects is the right not to have an existing benefit withdrawn without justification.
Article 4 of Law 10/2021 on remote working grants remote workers the same rights as employees who attend the workplace, except for those specifically linked to working on-site, and protects their remuneration conditions.
Employers must therefore review the collective bargaining agreement, employment contract and any internal agreements or policies before modifying this benefit.
When can employers stop providing meal vouchers?
The decisive factors are the conditions under which employees become entitled to meal vouchers and their intended purpose. These are the most common scenarios:
1. Meal vouchers compensate employees for eating away from home when attending the workplace
In this case, employers may stop providing them on remote working days. This approach was upheld by the Spanish Supreme Court rulings on meal vouchers (judgments of 19 and 20 March 2024) in certain cases involving employees who switched to remote working during the pandemic.
The Supreme Court judgment of 19 March 2024 considered, among other factors, the following three elements:
- The benefit compensated employees for meal expenses associated with working on-site away from home.
- Meal vouchers were not provided to employees who were already working remotely before the pandemic.
- It had not been established that the vouchers constituted salary, meaning that they formed part of the employee's remuneration.
These judgments do not provide general authorisation to withdraw meal vouchers. Whether employers can do so depends on the provisions of the applicable collective bargaining agreements, employment contracts or other agreements.
2. Meal vouchers are provided for each day actually worked, without requiring on-site attendance
If the collective bargaining agreement, employment contract or other agreement grants the benefit for each day actually worked, without requiring attendance at the workplace or compensation for expenses specifically associated with on-site work, remote working days may also qualify for this entitlement.
In these cases, excluding only remote working days changes the conditions under which the benefit is granted and may give rise to a claim based on unjustified unequal treatment, in accordance with Article 4 of Law 10/2021.
3. Meal vouchers are an established benefit or a more favourable employment condition
If meal vouchers constitute a contractual entitlement or an established benefit, their withdrawal cannot be justified solely by the transition to remote working.
Where withdrawal constitutes a substantial modification of working conditions, there must be economic, technical, organisational or production-related grounds, and the procedure established in Article 41 of the Spanish Workers' Statute must be followed.
If the entitlement is established in a statutory collective bargaining agreement, the rules governing the modification or non-application of its conditions must be respected, in accordance with Article 82.3 of the Workers' Statute.
The Supreme Court judgment of 18 November 2021 declared the collective withdrawal of the meal vouchers examined in that case null and void because the required procedure had not been followed.
For a more favourable employment condition to exist, it must be demonstrated that the employer intended to incorporate the benefit as an employee entitlement, either expressly or through its actions. The mere repetition of payments is not sufficient in itself, although a prolonged and deliberate practice may demonstrate such an intention.
Does the personal income tax exemption still apply?
Yes. Article 42.3(a) of Law 35/2006 on Personal Income Tax (IRPF) and Article 45 of its implementing regulations allow the personal income tax exemption for meal vouchers to be maintained during remote working, up to €11 per day. Any amount exceeding this limit is taxable, and the exemption also covers meal delivery costs.
However, the following requirements must be met for the tax exemption to apply:
- Meal vouchers must be used on the employee's working days.
- They must not be used on days when the employee is entitled to tax-exempt meal allowances.
- Vouchers must be issued in the employee's name, numbered and non-transferable. They must identify the issuing company and, when issued in paper format, state their face value.
- They must be used at restaurants or other catering establishments.
- Neither the employer nor third parties may reimburse the value of the meal vouchers.
- Unused amounts cannot be carried over from one day to another.
In addition, employers must maintain and retain an individual record of the vouchers provided.
The €11 daily amount is the tax-exempt limit, not an amount that employers are necessarily required to provide. The value of the benefit depends on what has been agreed.
Are meal vouchers subject to Social Security contributions?
Yes. The fact that meal vouchers are exempt from personal income tax does not mean they are exempt from Social Security contributions. Therefore, their full value is included in the Social Security contribution base, in accordance with Article 23 of the General Regulation on Contributions and Settlement of Other Social Security Rights.
What should employers review in their payroll?
- Check that the days on which meal vouchers are provided and the corresponding amounts comply with the applicable collective bargaining agreement, employment contract or other agreement.
- Verify that the amounts exempt from personal income tax correspond to the employee's working days and do not coincide with days on which the employee is entitled to tax-exempt meal allowances.
- Confirm that vouchers or cards are issued in the employee's name, numbered and non-transferable, that they are used at restaurants or other catering establishments, and that they do not allow refunds or the accumulation of unused amounts between days.
- Maintain an individual record of the vouchers provided and of on-site and remote working days.
- Ensure that payroll reflects Social Security contributions on the full value of the benefit.